Google falsely accused a father of abusing his child

Apparently, a worried father named Mark, from San Francisco, USA, is worried about the swelling in his child's genital area, and takes pictures of this part and sends it to the doctor. he does; Google mistakenly considered this image as child abuse, closed all accounts of this person and even opened the police to the matter. Mark) took a picture of his son's inner thigh (genital area) for a medical problem to send to his doctor. He felt that this part of his son's body was swollen and inflamed, and in order to make sure of the presence or absence of a problem, he took a picture of this part and sent it to the doctor. The doctor also sees the image and even writes a prescription for treatment.

BingMag.com Google falsely accused a father of abusing his child

Apparently, a worried father named Mark, from San Francisco, USA, is worried about the swelling in his child's genital area, and takes pictures of this part and sends it to the doctor. he does; Google mistakenly considered this image as child abuse, closed all accounts of this person and even opened the police to the matter. Mark) took a picture of his son's inner thigh (genital area) for a medical problem to send to his doctor. He felt that this part of his son's body was swollen and inflamed, and in order to make sure of the presence or absence of a problem, he took a picture of this part and sent it to the doctor. The doctor also sees the image and even writes a prescription for treatment.

But the story took off when this image was uploaded to the cloud. As soon as this happened, Google identified the image as child abuse and sent a report to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. This is what caused the police to open their eyes to the matter.

Two days after this image was uploaded to the cloud, Google blocked this person's user account. In general, every Google account in Mark's name was blocked, including the local Google WiFi service. According to the Times magazine, Google apparently even sent Mark a message because of this, telling him that the uploaded image was considered "harmful content" and thus was in strict violation of Google's policy in this area and may be illegal. . Mark later learns that Google has sent a report to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children and the San Francisco police are also following up on the matter. He was acquitted, but Google did not give up and kept his user accounts blocked. One of the company's spokesmen, Christa Maldon, said in this regard: "We behave in accordance with American laws in detecting sexual abuse of children and use a combination of hash matching technology and artificial intelligence to identify and remove it from our platform." .

BingMag.com Google falsely accused a father of abusing his child

Daniel Kahn Gilmore, a senior staff member of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) regarding this Google's move said:

These big companies have access to a large part of data and personal information about people's lives, but still do not have a correct understanding of the real life conditions of users. There are many things that make up the facts of our lives but these big companies don't consider it legal.

Gilmore also added:

Not that these systems have the ability to detect child abuse. They don't, my point is that sometimes their judgment gives people false positives and their lives can be completely turned upside down by machines. People who are affected by these events may make bad decisions because they have no reason to improve the situation. Of course, this happened in February 2021; When many medical centers were still closed due to the spread of the Corona virus and services were provided to people online. The picture that Mark recorded was at the request of the doctor's nurse. Google, however, identified the child's father as a defendant for uploading this image and did not unblock his user accounts even after the police report.

Google is apparently required by federal law to do so. Report potential uses to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children's CyberTipLine system. Last year, Google reported 621,583 similar cases to this system, among which 4,260 cases were sent to the authorities of this center, and according to the Times magazine, Mark's case was one of them.

All these events show that artificial intelligence still cannot be trusted to diagnose many different things.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.