Home > Art and cinema > Movies and series
Reading time estimate: 7 min

The questions that remained unanswered in the movie "Sinner"

BingMag.com The questions that remained unanswered in the movie 'Sinner'

The Netflix criminal mystery film, The Guilty, is a very complex story of a 911 operator and leaves some unanswered questions in the minds of the audience.


The film is a remake of a Danish film of the same name in 2018, starring Jake Gyllenhaal as Joe Baylor, a Los Angeles Police Department officer at the 911 Emergency Center. It is clear at the outset that Joe is awaiting trial for an incident that occurred to him while on duty a few months before the film's events. Joe begins his investigation to rescue Emily Lighton, a young woman who claims to have been abducted.

  • 9 thriller movies like "Sinner" to watch
  • What do critics say about "Sinner"?
  • Oscar 2022 prediction; Will Will Smith and Denzel Washington reunite?

The culprit focuses on Joe's efforts to help Emily, as well as the collapse of her professional and personal life. It is a tense and concise film, and Gyllenhaal's excellent performance has received rave reviews. Since the whole narrative takes place in one night and in one place, all the information of the film is conveyed through telephone calls and conversations, and many story lines are left to the imagination of the audience.

The culprit is a narrative full of It is a maze and a mystery, and its realistic framing leaves many questions unanswered. The style of saying and not showing and implicitly referring to concepts is very effective in other films, but this method leaves many sinful riddles unclear. Some of them may be easier to define than others, but others (despite sinful inspiration from another movie) are not easily solved.

Why did Joe kill the boy?

One of the twists and turns of the guilt story told throughout the film is that Joe kills a young man named Joseph while on duty. It is only when Joe tries to explain this that he is overwhelmed by intense emotions, so it is difficult to estimate the exact reason for Joe's action. Joe first claims to have killed Joseph at will and then states that he intended to punish him. He goes on to say that Joseph had hurt someone but could not confirm it with certainty, and even said out loud that he was skeptical. Finally, he stutters and says something about his father that is not clear at all. During Joe's emotional explanation, it is not clear why Joe committed the crime, and in fact, this means that even Joe himself does not know the reason for the incident.

Why Joe separated from his wife Is it?

BingMag.com The questions that remained unanswered in the movie 'Sinner'

It is clear from the beginning that Joe's honesty is in question His relationship with his wife, Jess, has also soured. It is easy to assume that the two are related, but there are different aspects to the film that show the opposite. Joe behaves violently several times throughout the film, and Jess seems to run away from his contacts, but somewhere in the film, he informs him that his current wife is negotiating with AFBI, which means that he is at least in part , In this case, supports Joe. Joe's daughter, Page, has also separated from him, and this probably has nothing to do with her work challenges. The presence of Jess and Page among sinful characters is very limited. Joe's anger and instability seem to be the cause of his family rift, but in any case, the film does not answer that question.

How did Oliver survive?

One of the culprits, Oliver, Emily and Henry's son, is severely injured after being left alone with his six-year-old sister, Abby, and looks set to die. When Emily confesses that she pulled the snakes out of the boy's belly, it is clear that the woman intended to harm her child. Officers reported blood all over the scene and a one- or two-year-old boy was seriously injured for an hour. The same officers both say that he is not breathing and their reaction shows that his injuries are terrible, but in the continuation and part of the plot of the guilty story, it turns out that Oliver has survived his injuries. It is not clear exactly how he survives (given the extent of the injuries and the duration of the injury) and the film leaves another question unanswered.

What will happen to Emily and Henry? Emily and Henry are Abby and Oliver's parents, and their future is when the final credits airs. The culprit is unknown. Emily had previously been treated for her mental illness before injuring Oliver, and if the boy really survived the events of the film, he would likely receive more intensive medical care. Henry also has a history of rape and escaped from the crime scene without informing the police and kidnapped his ex-wife during a process. In one of the twists of the guilty story, it turned out that he intended to put Emily in a safe place, but on the other hand, he left his six-year-old daughter, Abby, alone with the wounded Oliver. Given his artistic criminal record, he appears to be currently behind bars.

What will happen to Abby and Oliver? The future of children largely depends on the fate of their parents. It is safe to say that Emily will not be allowed to care for them, and if Henry is imprisoned, the children will most likely be placed with another family. At the end of the film, it is revealed that Oliver is alive and in the intensive care unit, but nothing is said about his real condition. So the future of children is also completely uncertain.

What will happen to Joe?

BingMag.com The questions that remained unanswered in the movie 'Sinner'

At the end of the film, Joe confesses to Emily that he had no reason to kill Joseph and that he killed him on purpose. Many other causes of the accident remain unknown, and so is the future and the atmosphere. Recent convictions of police officers (for similar crimes) provide for long prison terms, and Joe is likely to go through the same process. He will go to jail regardless of his guilt and remorse.

Does the culprit defend or condemn police violence?

After Screening, there were discussions about the exact position of the film about violence and police misconduct. Joe is not a callous first role. He exhibits a number of unstable and dangerous behaviors, and Joe sees himself as a victim until the events of the film show us the right perspective on him. While some believe that the perpetrator shows compassion for police violence, others believe that the film explores the horrific issue of how dangerous people can position themselves in power.

Of course, the unstable nature and atmosphere of the atmosphere and its unpleasant behavior with those around it mean that the film is more inclined to the case and the second theory. Making this ambiguous was a clever move by the film's director, Antoine Foucault, because taking a clear stand on such an important subject could disrupt the film's widespread appeal and discourage some audiences.

What is the Importance of Barley Headache and Inhalation Spray?

BingMag.com The questions that remained unanswered in the movie 'Sinner'

Probably the most confusing unanswered question , Has no clear explanation. The dependence of barley on inhalation spray is obvious. He uses the film most of the time and uses it in times of stress and difficulty to keep calm and cope with his limitations. Joe always uses this device when he is angry and has frequent headaches and tries to resolve the consequences of his actions, but there is no complete explanation for the cause of the headache or his use of spray, and this seems to be unanswered. It will remain.

The limited space and scene and the 90-minute duration of the film do not have much room to explore the broad concepts of the story. This may not be satisfying for some, but it adds to the realism of the film and creates an immersive experience. In some films, dealing with issues in a realistic way can be problematic, but the culprit is not, and provides a terrifying and familiar picture of law enforcement in modern society. The culprit may not answer every question and riddle he raises, but this makes the film more lasting in the memories.

Source: Screenrant

READ NEXT IN: art and cinema / movies and series

BingMag.com 10 actors who shine in supporting and supporting roles movies and series

In this article, you will get acquainted with 10 grade actors who shine in supporting and complementary roles and master the scenes with their exceptional and exemplary skills. Unforgettable moments c

BingMag.com 14 characters of the Paper House series from the most hated to the most popular movies and series

The Paper House series, also known as "Money Heist" in English, has been taking over the world for several years and has gained numerous fans. Found. With a compelling combination of emotional situati

BingMag.com 12 zombie-themed horror movies of all time from worst to best movies and series

According to the people of the Caribbean, and especially Haiti, zombies are creatures without the power of understanding and logic that lose their ability to reason at death. They give up and after de

BingMag.com Filming of Extraction 2 officially began movies and series

Netflix and Sam Hargreave announced hours before the start of filming of "Extraction 2" in the Czech Republic.