Criticism of the mini-series “Black Bird”; There are four prisons here

The series "Blackbird" should be classified in the continuation of the serialization process based on the life and circumstances of serial killers, which is especially popular with the TV audience. Compared to the epic series "Mindhunter" by David Fincher, they were made all over the world. Of course, there is a difference in this; The makers of "Blackbird" have pitted two criminals against each other, not a cop against a killer. The only thing that makes the difference between these two men is the type of crime they each committed. In this way, one is introduced as a reformable criminal who can be useful to the society, and the other is an embodied devil who sheds the blood of innocent girls and should be kept away from society forever. There is.

BingMag.com Criticism of the mini-series “Black Bird”; There are four prisons here

The series "Blackbird" should be classified in the continuation of the serialization process based on the life and circumstances of serial killers, which is especially popular with the TV audience. Compared to the epic series "Mindhunter" by David Fincher, they were made all over the world. Of course, there is a difference in this; The makers of "Blackbird" have pitted two criminals against each other, not a cop against a killer. The only thing that makes the difference between these two men is the type of crime they each committed. In this way, one is introduced as a reformable criminal who can be useful to the society, and the other is an embodied devil who sheds the blood of innocent girls and should be kept away from society forever. There is.

The strength of the "Black Bird" series is in creating a complex and ambiguous feeling towards the murderer. At one point in the story, one of the detectives involved in the case says: "It is not clear whether he is a complete idiot or a clever genius." This confusion of the police in recognizing the character of the suspect of crimes is also transmitted to the audience; In such a way that the audience does not know until the end of the series how they should feel about this man and how they should judge him. This type of audience sometimes remains wondering whether he is a genius or a fool. Ambiguity in the killer's characterization, along with Paul Walter Hauser's first-class performance in his role, is the most important achievement of the creators, otherwise the series would be severely affected in other ways.

As an example of the relationship between the two sides of the story (the same two prisoners). It doesn't form properly and is full of dramatic holes. The difference between these two people is so great that he gives his life to show various encounters and conflicts, until the breath of the audience is trapped in his chest. Unfortunately, except for one or two times, the great potential of these two different worlds of two completely different people has not been used well; The first time is when everyone under the killer is cleaning up the prison cafeteria after a crazy riot. This part is so well done that it flows like electricity and wind and explains the relationship between the two sides well. But as the expectation rises, the continuation of the development process of this relationship remains slow until finally, in the final part and at the time of the eruption of anger on both sides, the capacities of the two characters are used again for a few short minutes.

On the other hand, the creators of the series plant seeds here and there, but when they give enough weight, they do not use them. For example, the cautious and respectful relationship of James or the main character of the story with the head of a mafia organization, which can be the basis of a full-fledged suspense, is abandoned from one place to the next and does not find any dramatic use. Or the trouble and blackmail caused by one of the prison guards does not affect the flow of the drama, and the producers sometimes only touch on it, to the extent that it can be removed and thrown away without harming the structure of the work. In the end, it is as if the small plots of the series have no purpose except to make the drama fatter and do not help to find the consistency of Shah Pirang.

It was possible to get rid of all these meaningless stories and discuss the relationship between the two main characters. The fighting capacity focused and made a more coherent work, he could not have jumped from one step to the other and became a companion and synchronist of two people who have dozens and hundreds of stories to tell. This kind of exciting six episodes were made, which does not jump from one branch to another and focuses on one point. It is in such a framework that even James's relationship with that female policewoman, which could have been a relationship full of misunderstandings, goes to waste and does not work properly.

The result of all this is that the change and evolution of the main character is also unbelievable. fail Because, contrary to the claims of the police department, neither the prison in the film is scary enough, nor its inmates that dangerous. In order to bring about the great change that the judge in the James case suggests at the end, first of all, a proper prison must be built so that the audience can feel the hardships of life there with all their being, not that the prison is depicted as a free environment. Anyone can go wherever they want at any moment for any reason and be called only to eat and sleep and only care about the man who is standing in front of them on the other side of the corridor.

*Titer, several The line is from the poem "Kafir" by Ahmed Shalomust.

Certification of the mini-series "Black Bird"

Creator: Denis Lehan
Based on: the book "Relationship with Satan: A A lost hero, a serial killer, and a dangerous bargain for redemption" by James Kane and Hillel Levin
Starring: Taron Egerton, Paul Walter Hauser, Sepideh Mafi, Greg Keener and Ray Liotta

Story Summary : A young man named James managed to earn good money through drug trafficking. During these years, he has paid for his father and lived a luxurious life for himself. One day, the police raid his house, and after being arrested, he is sentenced to ten years in state prison. One day, the prosecutor along with a The FBI agent approaches James in the prison and tells him that due to his high ability to communicate with people, he is a good candidate to be transferred to another prison and communicate with a serial killer in exchange for getting enough information to pardon him. and be released from prison; All James has to do is find the burial place of one of the dead...

Rotten Tomatoes Series Rating: 97%
Author Rating: 2 out of 5

Miniseries Review "Black Bird" is the personal opinion of the author and not necessarily the position of BingMag.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.