Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

The two fantasy series "Dragon Family" and "Rings of Power" have many points in common, but one has significant advantages over the other. Currently, we are in a period where big studios and companies use their intellectual property (the right to adapt various works) to highlight and popularize their online streaming networks, as a banner so that more audience will come to their network. This fall, we are witnessing the competition of two of the most popular fantasy franchises in history: the prequel to the series "Game of Thrones", the series "Dragon Family", which is the flagship of the HBO network, and the adaptation of Azadi, which is based on the works of J. R. R. Tolkien created the series "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power", which is the flagship of the Amazon network and is currently the highest-grossing series in history. Both of these series are adapted from the richest works of fantasy, and fans who are used to the strong presence of the fantasy genre on television with "Game of Thrones" will go to these two series to quench their thirst, hoping not to be disappointed. /p>

BingMag.com Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

The two fantasy series "Dragon Family" and "Rings of Power" have many points in common, but one has significant advantages over the other. Currently, we are in a period where big studios and companies use their intellectual property (the right to adapt various works) to highlight and popularize their online streaming networks, as a banner so that more audience will come to their network. This fall, we are witnessing the competition of two of the most popular fantasy franchises in history: the prequel to the series "Game of Thrones", the series "Dragon Family", which is the flagship of the HBO network, and the adaptation of Azadi, which is based on the works of J. R. R. Tolkien created the series "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power", which is the flagship of the Amazon network and is currently the highest-grossing series in history. Both of these series are adapted from the richest works of fantasy, and fans who are used to the strong presence of the fantasy genre on television with "Game of Thrones" will go to these two series to quench their thirst, hoping not to be disappointed. /p>

However, going into these two series may be challenging for those who are not familiar with the source material or who have not watched Game of Thrones, The Lord of the Rings trilogy, and The Hobbit trilogy. It takes a lot of commitment and time to sit down to watch House of Dragons and watch all 8 seasons of Game of Thrones, or to watch The Rings of Power and watch the first six films in the Lord of the Rings franchise and then move on to the series. Come on, not every audience will spend this amount of time and commitment just to watch a series; If they want to go to the hundreds of thousands of words written by the authors, that is, George R. R. Martin and J. R. R. Tolkien, they should now read "A Song of Ice and Fire" and all Tolkien's books, including "The Silmarillion". When we talk about history and mythology, neither of the series "Dragon Family" and "Rings of Power" lack anything. So many families, magical creatures, different realms, kingdoms, important characters, castles, and historical events that these lucky audiences have to read about. Even swords have their own names in the world of these two franchises! Sean Bean (played by Boromir and Ned Stark) also dies in Game of Thrones and Lord of the Rings, so keeping the two series separate may be difficult for a newbie who doesn't know anything. (Fun fact: Ned Stark's childhood actor in Game of Thrones is the same actor who now plays Al Rand in Rings of Power. Another case of confusion!)

  • The history of witches in Middle-earth; Is the mysterious man in "Rings of Power" a wizard?

Both of these prequels are adapted from a source written by the author himself

BingMag.com Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

Both of the mentioned series, "Dragon Family" and "Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power" are pre-grossing. But advances have differences. Some prequels rely on the audience's knowledge and mastery of the story and rely heavily on the audience being aware of the source of the adaptation and its intricacies. While the rest of the prequels maintain their independence and even try to be an easier starting point for the audience to enter the story world (eg Westeros) instead of the main work (eg Game of Thrones) and that is why they are more popular than expected. appear and send a new wave of audiences towards the original work and even the source of adaptation. The first few episodes of both series were like a reward for long-time fans of Martin and Tolkien's works. /p>

The "Dragon Family" series is two full centuries away from the events of "Game of Thrones", Night King and the war of the self-proclaimed kings of Westerosi. Although "House of Dragons" shows us the same familiar Westeros as "Game of Thrones", they have no identical characters. In fact, the hints and references of "Game of Thrones" to the characters of "Dragon Family" are so few and insignificant that the series does not have any problems with the audience and expectations created in "Game of Thrones" regarding its characters. For example, if Damon Targaryen and Rhaenyra Targaryen were constantly talked about in "Game of Thrones" and things were attributed to them, "Dragon Family" had to be loyal to them. As in the appearance of some castles and cities of Westeros, it has to follow what is said in "Game of Thrones". But "Rings of Power" does not have this advantage, because some characters from the "Lord of the Rings" trilogy are also present in "Rings of Power" thanks to the long life of elves (who are almost immortal). Characters such as Galadriel played by Merfid Clarke, Elrand played by Robert Aramaio, who portray younger versions of these characters in "Rings of Power". Perhaps one of the charms of the series is watching this path The characters go through the journey to reach the glory we saw in The Lord of the Rings.

The ultimate charm of any work is in the details, and The Rings of Power doesn't spend much time on details.

BingMag.com Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

The events of the "Rings of Power" series are complete with the "Lord of the Rings" story. has eaten. In "Rings of Power" we're going to see Sauron's first fall, witness the making of the Rings of Power, including Sauron's Ring, and find out why the Elves' arrival at Valinor is connected to the whole adventure of Frodo Baggins and the Ringmates. "The Rings of Power" and "The Lord of the Rings" are thousands of years apart, but the characters, events, and stories in general are heavily influenced by each other. Maybe that's why the "Rings of Power" series never spends time recounting and re-explaining these events and highlighting their importance. Issues such as the symbol of Sauron and the journey of the elves to Valinor are clearly of great importance, but the narrative of "Rings of Power" does not allow the audience to go into details, and this is where "Rings of Power" falls short of "House of Dragons". Perhaps this is the reason for the large and significant difference in the number of viewers of these two series.

If we want to compare, it should be said that the story of "Dragon Family" filled us with details wherever necessary. In the first part, which is called "Successors of the Dragon", it deals with the succession of King Jihiris, who was called the Old King (which Viserys becomes king), and the succession of Viserys himself, which has become the main problem of the Targaryen family. "Descendants of the Dragon" focuses entirely on this internal conflict of the Targaryen family and gives the audience all the details it needs. King Viserys I, played by Paddy Considine, is heartbroken and grieving after the death of his wife and newborn son. In the first episode of the series, we clearly see a conflict within the family. Viserys chooses princess Rhaenyra Targaryen played by Millie Alcock as his successor so that his brother Damon Targaryen played by Matt Smith, who is a violent and reckless prince, will never become king and will not endanger the kingdom with his recklessness and cause division among the Westerosi lords. From the very beginning, "Dragon Family" talks about universal themes such as the limitations of patriarchy, family dynasties and their challenges, and the ignorance of the rich. li>

However, in "Rings of Power" the main conflict is not even clear. The series "Rings of Power" does not even introduce us to all the main characters of the series in the first two episodes. We are still getting to know different regions and different races such as humans, dwarves, elves and harefoots (the same hobbits) and are involved in their cultural differences and different names. But in the first episode, "Dragon Family" the series consciously keeps us within the borders of King's Landing (the capital) and Dragonstone.

"Rings of Power" has a bigger story to tell, but "Dragon Family" is more focused

BingMag.com Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

Both series first start with an introduction that tells the story The main one is under its influence. House of Dragons explains with its introduction why Viserys sits on the Iron Throne and why a Targaryen must always rule Westeros, thus also explaining its connection to Game of Thrones. There are also references to the past, for example the conquest of Aegon (the first Targaryen king who united all of Westeros) is mentioned enough in the conversations for the audience to understand its importance. Viserys even explains A Song of Ice and Fire (the name of the book series) to his daughter Rhaenyra and talks about a great prophecy that refers to the Night King and the White Walkers. In contrast, the series "Rings of Power" opens with a sweeping scene that shows us the birth and rise of Middle-earth. This is where if you are a new audience who is not familiar with Tolkien's world, you should carefully look at each scene, because knowing the consequences of the war against Morgoth and the effect it has on Middle-earth is necessary to understand the overall story of the series.

What's admirable about both series is that both prioritize their female protagonists: Rhaenyra Targaryen and Galadriel. While both of these characters are fascinating in their own right, the young princess, Rhaenyra, is a more fleshed-out character than the warrior and immortal elf who has lived for thousands of years. Rhynera has to deal with a responsibility she never asked for, is constantly belittled by superior men, and has to face challenges for the smallest things. Also, because the audience has already seen Damon Targaryen, Rhaenyra's uncle, how harshly he treats the people of the city, he understands why Rhaenyra has to dedicate herself to this responsibility and accept the succession with open arms; Daemon will be an evil king.

But the path that Galadriel's character must take is not as clear and clear as Rhynyra's path. Galadriel is deeply involved in her mission against evil, so much so that she is willing to leave her ship and not go to heaven (Valinor). Obviously, such a character has no common ground to the audience It does not have and does not arouse the viewers' identification. The death of Galadriel's brother Finrad could have been what brought him closer to the audience. After all, everyone understands the grief of losing loved ones, but the series "Rings of Power" uses the death of Galadriel's brother more to show the fact that the demon is still He roams around Middle-earth using and we don't see anything of Galadriel's emotions. Sauron himself is only present in flashbacks (that too once). Therefore, without us seeing Sauron, the importance of Galadriel fades in our minds; Because all we see is a series of catastrophic events that are not even connected. (Are the trolls they encounter in the cave and the sea monster Galadriel is running from related? Are they related to Saero? No!) And even if the two-fire fans of the "Lord of the Rings" franchise know how important El Rand's mission is and that the rings of power were created ends, the new audience will not know anything and it is not unlikely that they will get tired of the aimlessness of the series and its characters.

There is also the issue of tone. "Dragon Family" introduces itself as a political thriller series that also has dragons. But "Rings of Power" carries forward a vast epic story. However, in the first few episodes, Rings of Power only shows us a brief action scene that shows Galadriel fighting a monster in a cave, after which the entire first hour is spent showing Middle-earth. . However, "Dragon Family" deftly challenges its own limitations. In the first part, we see small-scale fights, the duel of the knights and the show of power of the golden cloaks in the streets of the capital. But in the third episode, "The Second of His Name," we see Daemon Targaryen fighting Kragas Darhar with House Velarion's army.

House of Dragons doesn't have the copyright issues of Rings of Power

BingMag.com Comparison of “Dragon Family” and “Rings of Power”; Which series is better for the uninformed audience?

If we want to be fair, we should note this important point It should be noted that the production team of "Rings of Power" has limitations that the producers of "Dragon Family" do not have. The author of the books that "Game of Thrones" and "Dragon Family" were adapted from, namely George R. R. Martin is personally involved as a producer in the "Dragon Family" series and can easily answer any question and fill in any blanks in the story world. An advantage that "Rings of Power" and its creators do not have.

Amazon has the right to make certain parts of Tolkien's stories, but not all of them. According to the current contract, Amazon only has the right to make parts that revolve around "The Hobbit" and "The Lord of the Rings" and they cannot use many other stories and books written in Middle-earth; Like "The Silmarillion", which ironically deals in detail with the second age of Middle-earth, that is, exactly the period in which the "Rings of Power" series takes place. Tolkien's family has never welcomed and supported the adaptation of this author's stories. Tolkien's son, Christopher, also criticized Peter Jackson's "Lord of the Rings" trilogy and was not satisfied with any of them. "Rings"?

Ultimately, one must conclude that television viewers have endless series ready to watch. Today, despite the online streaming networks that are constantly producing various series as fast as possible, no one is short of series. But we always have our favorite series that we know we're going to watch every week and follow for years. We don't have this commitment to all the series, we don't have the time for it either, so we have to choose wisely which series is going to take up most of our time. "Dragon Family" promises a brilliant series; A great series for those who want to go to Westeros for the first time. The Rings of Power, however, is a better choice for an audience familiar with the worlds of The Lord of the Rings and Middle Earth, for those who have been there and come back again! ("There and back again.")

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.