Home > Art and cinema > Movies and series
Reading time estimate: 26 min

17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

Disney's recent efforts to recreate its classic live-action animation have been well-received by critics, and in most cases have captured the box office for a while. However, not all cases follow this rule and have not become lasting masterpieces.

According to a report released by CNBC in July 2019, Disney has been live-action since the release of Alice in Wonderland. in Wonderland) had more than $ 7 billion in funding for the company in 2010. This figure simply proves the reason for the interest in making live action in the last few years.

He referred to "Cruella", but as with all Disney first-rate remakes, there are works that have been criticized and received harsh reactions. Part of this criticism is due to the fact that the original animation is miles ahead of its remade counterpart, and some of the films are fraught with problems, large and small, that make watching them a painful experience.

A brief look at Metacritic and Raton Tomitoz scores reveals which live action is a worthy replacement for the classics and which has been widely ridiculed. We examine the works made on the basis of their popularity and the reasons for their acceptance or dislike of these works; So if you are a fan of Disney flashy works, stay tuned.

17. Alice Through the Looking Glass )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release year: 2016
  • Director: James Babin
  • Actors: Mia Washikowska, Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, Ann Hathaway, Alan Rickman , Sasha Baron Cohen
  • IMDb rating for movie: 6.2 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz Score: 28 out of 100
  • Metacritic Score: 34 out of 100

Alice in Beyond the Mirror is the second part of "Alice in Wonderland", which was released in 2010 and was well received by the audience. Of course, this movie was not one of the most popular live-action critics, and it received negative reactions. However, Alice on the other side of the mirror was so weak that the first part has a special place in the hearts of critics compared to that!

There are many reasons for There's why Alice on the Other Side of the Mirror is Disney's worst live-action, but most importantly, it can't justify its existence. . The production design of this film seems to show a gloomy landscape of computer special effects. In addition, it is full of vague grotesque characters and a color palette that uses almost any color you can think of. The cast is either too sleepy or overly exaggerated.

Vox critic Emily Vanderorf similarly criticized computer special effects: "The high level of color use in the film only indicates fake special effects. "The only thing I can say about Alice in the Mirror is that we seem to be dealing with a video game in the mid-1990s, and the actors are moving against a fake digital background." On the other side of the mirror, despite its beautiful appearance and glaze, it does not become a phenomenon in Wonderland, and it is one of those live actions that you probably will not remember watching it or not a few years later.

16- 102 Spotted Dogs (102 Dalmatians )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release Year: 000
  • Director: Kevin Lima
  • Actors : Glenn Close, Alice Evans, Evan Griffid, Gerard Depardieu, Eric Idel, Ian Richardson
  • IMDb rating for the film : 4.9 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz movie rating: 31 out of 100
  • Metacritic movie rating: 35 out of 100

102 dogs Spotted is not really a typical remake of the classic Disney animation, but a sequel to the live-action "101 Spotted Dogs" (101 Dalmatians) released in 1996. Maybe if it was an independent work and it told its new story about puppies, it would not be criticized so much, but the main problem is that 102 Spotted Dogs have nothing to offer compared to the first part and can not impress the audience.>

A few years after the events of the first part, we see Corolla released from prison. A woman who pretends to be corrected and will not bother other dogs, but is inherently a well-dressed devil and still seeks to carry out her nefarious plots. "Some of the chases are fun, but the dogs get out of the main role in the film and are replaced by weird humans," Khaledar explains. As a result, the love and affection that the puppies created in the audience disappears. " However, 102 Spotted Dogs also has positive aspects, including its costume design, which earned the Oscar nomination for Best Costume Design for the film, but overall the main character and other sub-characters compared to Disney's latest live-action Corolla , Has nothing to offer.

15- Malficent: Mistress of Evil

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release year: 2019
  • Director: Joachim Running
  • Actors: Angelina Jolie, L. Fanning, Chowitel Agiofor, Sam Riley, Ed Screen
  • IMDb rating for movie: 6.6 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz rating for movie: 39 Out of 100
  • Metacritic Score to Movie: 43 out of 100

"Maleficent" was first released in 2014 and One of Disney's live-action shows was a new look at its classics He had a company. The story is about the evil wizard of the beautiful dormant animated Malficent, who, unlike the original source, is not very evil in nature, and some of his evil deeds are somewhat understandable. The contract, in addition to the audience, was accompanied by positive reactions from critics. For this reason, Disney thought of making a second part, the story of which took place along the first part. The box office was not a success either. In this episode, Aurora and Maleficent reach peace together and live like a real mother and daughter and rule their land. Everything is perfect until Aurora's beloved head is found in a foreign land. It is also more fancy than the first part and has a darker atmosphere. However, the film failed to attract the attention of critics.

New York Times critic Manola Dargis wrote about the film: "In 2014, instead of Prince, Malficent succeeded in Aurora Wake up. "This is not a new sequel, but a poisonous and sweet invitation to sleep again." In any case, Malficent: The Demon Lady is a beautiful and glazed movie that can be somewhat appealing to fans of the first episode, but has nothing to offer compared to the original source.

14-101 Spotted Dogs (101 Dalmatians )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release Year: 1996
  • Director: Steven Herk
  • Actors: <//> Glenn Close, Jeff Daniels, Julie Richardson, Hugh Laurie, Mark Williams, John Shrapnel
  • IMDb rating: strong> 5.7 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz Score to Movie: 41 out of 100
  • Metacritic Score to Movie: 49 From 100

Long before Disney released its modern live action with "Alice in Wonderland," it proved with the remake of 101 Spotted Dogs that animation could be a feature. Added to colorful and glazed films.

101 Spotted Dogs One of It is the most entertaining Disney animated classic, first released in 1961 and captivating the hearts of fans by showing the life of cute puppies. The remake included many of the original German animations and was well received at the box office, but received negative reviews from critics, most of whom were behind the original source.

101 Spotted Dogs There is no doubt, but fans of the original film think that its softness and charm have diminished. The original plot remains intact, but the story is too tight to fit into the film. " Ninety AD is one of their favorite live-action shows, but it fully proves the hypothesis that any film that gets the audience's attention does not necessarily have to be 100% positively received by critics.

13- Dumbo ( Dumbo )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release Year: 2019
  • Director: Tim Burton
  • Actors: Colin Farrell, Eva Green, Michael Keaton, Danny DeVito
  • IMDb rating to: strong> 6.3 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz points to film: 46 out of 100
  • Metacritic points to film: 51 From 100

Disney in line with b Reconstruction of his old works, this time he decided to turn Dumbo into a colorful and glazed live action. Coincidentally, he came up with different options that, at least on paper, could do the job best. When Tim Burton was named director of the film, critics were very curious to see the result, but contrary to expectations, the result did not become a cinematic masterpiece and instead is considered one of the weakest works of Tim Burton's career.

The story of this live-action is more or less in line with the original animation; The baby elephant lives in a circus with large corners, which people call ridiculous. Until the flying talent is discovered by the circus owners, and from now on, profiteers and malicious people seek to take over Dumbo. "Tim Burton's dumbbell is both too much and not enough. "Screenwriter Tim Burton and Irene Krueger significantly expanded the features of the 64-minute animation, adding new human characters to the film, but the main problem is that they could not develop them except by adding a few superficial features."

Of course, the production design and costumes of the film were met with positive reactions. In many critiques, along with pointing out the meaninglessness of the film, its visual beauty was praised. In any case, Tim Burton's Dumbo, despite all the hopes, turned into a remake that is significantly behind the original version and is not engraved in the memories.

12. Alice in Wonderland ( Alice in Wonderland )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Year of Release: 2010
  • Director: Tim Burton
  • Actors: Johnny Depp , Anne Hathaway, Helena Bonham Carter, Crispin Glover, Alan Rickman, Lenzie Duncan
  • IMDb rating to: 6 4. out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz Score to Movie: 51 out of 100
  • Metacritic Score to Movie: 53 out of 100

Alice in Wonderland can be considered the first live-action Disney that was made in a modern style, and by the way, the company also made a very good profit. When Tim Burton directed this famous adaptation of Louis Carroll, the film was expected to be a memorable one with its unique style, but the result did not go as expected, at least for the critics.

Many critics praised it. The film's beautiful costume design was believed to be too much of a fantasy aspect of Alice in Wonderland by Tim Burton, and that shatters the audience's imagination of this nostalgic classic.

Alice in Wonderland This is the seventh collaboration between Johnny Depp and Tim Burton, which is considered by many to be one of the weakest performances of this powerful actor in recent years. "Alice in Wonderland is a place where Depp first feels overwhelmed by his old director," wrote Boston Globe critic Tai Bar. Playing the role of this crazy man allows Johnny Depp to rebel. Her performance is not bad as long as you can erase her horrible dance from your mind. In fact, we are on the side of a lack of structure. " Finally, given the financial contribution Alice made to Disney in Wonderland, the audience seems to disagree and enjoy watching the film.

11- Lady and Vulgar ( Lady and the Tramp )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release Year: 2019
  • Director: Charlie Bean
  • Actors : Chair Clemens, Thomas Mann, Yvette Nicole Brown, Adrian Martinez, Arturo Castro
  • IMDb Score: </6.3>
  • Raton Tomitoz Score: 65 out of 100
  • Metacritic Score: 48 out of 100

Lady and the Tramp was one of the first live-action shows to be made exclusively for Disney Plus. Although the film was never released in cinemas, it had many of the characteristics of its counterparts, and just like them, it met with mixed reactions, some praising and others condemning the film.

The story of the little lady and the stray And it is more like the original animation and follows the story of a dog named Lady who is displaced by the journey of her guardians in the streets and is forced to spend all her time with stray dogs with strange creatures, despite her previous aristocratic life.

Ashley Dee Stevens, a critic of the Salon, called The Lady and the Stray incapable of expressing even the most rudimentary level of emotion: "The time of the new Lady and the Stray is about half an hour longer than the original version. Of course, this extra time does not provide anything to the audience, and only 103 minutes witness the talking, crying, laughing and flirting of dogs whose movements are controlled in an animated way. The combination of animation and live-action creates a strange emotional inconsistency. "

Of course, not all the comments about this live-action were too bad. For example, Indywire critic David Ehrlich praises the performance of film actors, including Sam Elliott, but in the opinion of this optimistic critic, both live action lady and stray are made with the same low expectations and indifferent feeling that most Disney Plus audiences watch while watching the exclusive works of this platform. There is.

Finally, despite all the contradictory reactions and criticisms, Lady and the Tramp proved well that the novelty and excitement of playing a movie from an Internet platform can not cover the obvious flaws of a work.

>

10- ( The Lion King )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • Release Year: 2019
  • Director: John Favreau
  • Voice actors: Donald Glover, James Earl Jones, Seth Rogen, Billy Eikner, Beyonce
  • Score IMDb To Movie: 6.8 out of 10
  • Raton Tomitoz Score to Movie: 52 out of 100
  • Metacritic Score To the movie: 55 of 100

Disney decided to unveil the Lion King as the third live action of 2019 after Dumbo and Aladdin. The remake was a resounding success at the box office, but received rave reviews. Opinions about Disney's recent live-action were very different; The computer's special effects and soundtrack received international acclaim, but most audiences believed that John Favreau's Lion King had nothing new to offer and was clearly behind his animated counterpart.

His name is Simba, who has a good life with his father Mofasa, the king of the forest, and endures the problems of the world with him. Until Mofasa is killed by his evil brother and Simba runs away for years after being accused of killing his father. He has to live in a new environment with strange western animals and prepare for revenge.

NPR critic Justin Chang wrote about The Lion King: Or perhaps the most expensive safari karaoke video in the world. "The film does not smell of artistic techniques and fidelity to the original text." The special and few strong vocal performances did not make him want to leave the cinema. .

9- (Aladdin )

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2019
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 6.9 10
  • : 57 100
  • : 53 100

. . . .

Stylecaster .

consequence : . .

.

8- (Maleficent)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2014
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 7 10
  • : 54 100
  • : 56 100

1959 .

. .

: . . .

. . .

. .

  • 10

7- (Beauty and the Beast)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2017
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 7.1 10
  • : 71 100
  • : 65 100

. .

. .

.

.

6- (Mulan)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2020
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 5.7 10
  • : 73 100
  • : 66 100

. .

.

. : . .

. .

. .

.

5- (Christopher Robin)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2018
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 7.3 10
  • : 72 100
  • : 60 100

. . .

.

. .

. Little White Lies . .

: . .

4- (Cruella)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2021
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 7.4 10
  • : 74 100
  • : 59 100

101 . .

. .

Mashable : .

. 1970 .

. .

. .

3- (Rudyard Kiplings The Jungle Book)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 1994
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 6 10
  • : 80 100
  • : 63 100

1994 .

. . : . .

1994 .

2- (Cinderella)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2015
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 6.9 10
  • : 84 100
  • : 67 100

. .

: . . - .

. .

. .

1- (The Jungle Book)

BingMag.com 17 remakes of Disney animations from best to worst

  • : 2016
  • :
  • :
  • IMDb : 7.4 10
  • : 94 100
  • : 77 100

1994 . 2016 .

. .

. Uproxx : .

.

.


Source: looper

READ NEXT IN: art and cinema / movies and series

BingMag.com 10 actors who shine in supporting and supporting roles movies and series

In this article, you will get acquainted with 10 grade actors who shine in supporting and complementary roles and master the scenes with their exceptional and exemplary skills. Unforgettable moments c

BingMag.com 14 characters of the Paper House series from the most hated to the most popular movies and series

The Paper House series, also known as "Money Heist" in English, has been taking over the world for several years and has gained numerous fans. Found. With a compelling combination of emotional situati

BingMag.com 12 zombie-themed horror movies of all time from worst to best movies and series

According to the people of the Caribbean, and especially Haiti, zombies are creatures without the power of understanding and logic that lose their ability to reason at death. They give up and after de

BingMag.com Filming of Extraction 2 officially began movies and series

Netflix and Sam Hargreave announced hours before the start of filming of "Extraction 2" in the Czech Republic.